Wednesday, July 16, 2003
Designing for Educators or Students? 
I threw together this quick scenario to show some of the issues I've been stuck on lately: the tyranny of curriculum (and testing), teachers' desire to control learning, the value of for-fee online content, and student motivation in self-directed learning....

Let's say I'm designing a piece of educational software teaching high school students about self-employment. In my initial research, I find out that students want to know which small-business opportunities can make them the most money in the shortest amount of time. In sharp contrast, I find that educators want the software to align with the administration's career-development standards and they want students to learn the step-by-step process of setting up a business. So students and teachers have different goals, and I only get paid if teachers buy the software.

The majority of our teacher/customers say they want a specific structure, preferably sequential with limited navigation options so students stay on-task, which isn't constructivist at all, but keeps them sane in the computer lab. It seems that they're happiest if we create a digital textbook that satisfies prescribed outcomes, with a few multimedia elements for so-called motivation. The students are just jumping through hoops, because they can see from the very first screen that they're probably not going to get what they want...at least not any time soon.

Instead of engaging in the carefully-designed step-by-step interactive business plan module and "learning" about business licensing, a student can do a couple of searches in Google (which she already has open in another window) and gradually figure out which entrepreneurial opportunities have the best time-to-profit ratio.

The student starting down this path in Google is in control of her learning, more motivated, and more likely to retain what she learns. She probably won't learn about the nuances of business licenses in her exploration, but if she's motivated enough by what she finds and actually pursues it further, she'll eventually do another search (or find someone who knows something about it) and learn about licensing at exactly the right moment. Same information, but more likely to be learned, valued and applied. The only problem in a school setting is that this urge to check it out is unlikely to occur when the education system demands that she check it out, which either erases the possibility of it ever occurring, or she'll do it on her own time.

The secondary issue is the role and viability of commercial learning materials. In a virtual classroom where students learn how to find their own sources, weigh their credibility, and design their own paths to knowledge on the web (and through networked experts and collaborators)....why would they need to pay for content?

Permanent Link  |  Home  |  

Post a Comment

Welcome to Jeremy Hiebert's instructional design and technology blog. Feel free to comment on postings, or e-mail me. Check out my personal/family blog at your own risk.

More about me...
  • Lifestylism
    I'm also studying how people envision their future lifestyles as the basis for a new web application.


May 2003  
June 2003  
July 2003  
August 2003  
September 2003  
October 2003  
November 2003  
December 2003  
January 2004  
February 2004  
March 2004  
April 2004  
May 2004  
June 2004  
July 2004  
August 2004  
September 2004  
October 2004  
November 2004  
December 2004  
January 2005  
February 2005  
March 2005  
April 2005  
May 2005  
June 2005  
July 2005  
August 2005  
September 2005  
October 2005  
November 2005  
December 2005  
January 2006  
February 2006  
March 2006  
April 2006  
May 2006  
June 2006  
July 2006  
August 2006  
September 2006  
October 2006  
November 2006  
December 2006  
January 2007  
February 2007  
March 2007  
April 2007  
May 2007  
June 2007  
July 2007  
June 2008  
This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?

Atom Feed

Listed on BlogsCanada

Listed on BlogShares

Jeremy Hiebert personal site